Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Charles A Roseberry's avatar

Covered a lot of ground, John, and covered it well. I totally agree that Justin Herbert was handicapped by coaching, or lack thereof during his Oregon tenure. Might even be worse at the Chargers so far. I think the potential has improved. One thing that seems to always be overlooked with Herbert is his intelligence; as I recall he graduated pre-med at Oregon with a 4 plus gpa. Just sayin,' Charlie

Expand full comment
John Smith's avatar

I am starting to wonder if there was something more beneath the surface of Smith's departure, the abruptness of it and the apparent anger as evidenced by the dump of gear at Goodwill. Let's be real, MSU gives him more money, and that is it. You can talk about resources, NIL, etc, but he is not going to WIN any more games then had he stayed put. For West Coast person, East Lansing is awful.

He seems to have bailed fast and with emotion, not just the money. We won't have answers anytime soon, but it's just something on my mind I can only really share with this crew.

Expand full comment
108 more comments...

No posts