4 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
Brian M's avatar

As I wrote that, I thought about Fouts. But for someone who stood out at his position with no real equals while he played, it was Rashad. Fouts had Marino and others to contend with. Renfro benefited from playing for Dallas. He was not as good as Rashad. Mariota has had a lackluster NFL career (I am only going by their NFL standings) similar to Derek Anderson (never a Heisman candidate). Van Brocklin was better known as a coach in the NFL than a player, but that might also be just how long ago he was a player so hard to compare.

Expand full comment
The Real Rich's avatar

Yeah, I misunderstood...you're talking about their pro performance, and I was speaking about their college careers. Agree with you on the pro performance, although Van Brocklin and Fouts were clearly the 1-2 (in either order) in the pros...IMHO.

Expand full comment
Brian M's avatar

I will go Fouts #3. But I am probably being a Vikings homer

Expand full comment
The Real Rich's avatar

You a "homer", Brian...good lordy...impossible!

Expand full comment